BYS Black Pearlised Liquid Eyeliner kinda sucks, to be honest. It stings during application, though it does go on smoothly. Wear starts off promising, but flaking will occur. Color payoff leaves something to be desired. The black shade is only remotely black, its really more a blue tinged dark grey. Its not all terrible though; the brush applicator is great and really easy to use. The $4 price tag is super reasonable, especially by Australian standards. I do not recommend the BYS Pearlised Liquid Eyeliner. I'm just gonna go ahead and toss this liner out now.